New Bethel Ordinary Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to New Bethel Ordinary, a delightful pizza haven located at 8838 Southeastern Ave, Indianapolis. Here, the menu is bursting with options that cater to every palate, featuring a range of appetizers, hearty wings, and refreshing salads, alongside their signature pizzas that redefine traditional American fare.
- Appetizers: Start your meal with tempting choices like hand-breaded Chicken Strips or the flavorful New Bethel Nachos.
- Wings: Enjoy both traditional and boneless wings, perfect for sharing or indulging solo.
- Salads: Fresh options like the Chef Salad and Chicken Caesar add a nutritious touch to your feast.
With its casual atmosphere, outdoor seating, and variety of vegetarian options, New Bethel Ordinary is an excellent choice for families and groups alike. Whether dining in or enjoying takeout, you’ll find something to love on this enticing menu.
Appetizers
Breadsticks
Nacho Cheese, Pizza Sauce, Garlic Butter
Potato Skins
Cheese, Bacon, Ranch, Sour Cream
Chicken Strips
Hand Breaded or Grilled, Choice of Sauce
Quesadilla
Traditional, BBQ, Buffalo Pico, Jalapeno, Lettuce, Salsa
Fried Ravioli
Marinara
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Garlic Toast, Mozzarella, Pizza Sauce
Loaded Fries
Cheese, Bacon, Ranch, Sour Cream
Fried Cauliflower
Ranch
Beer Battered Onion Rings
Petal Dipping Sauce
New Bethel Nachos
Tortilla Chips, White Queso, BBQ Sauce, Pico, Guacamole, Sour Cream
Tenderloin Strips
Hand-Breaded or Grilled, Horseradish Sauce, Ranch
Breaded Mushrooms
Ranch
Mozzarella Sticks
Marinara
Traditional Bone in Wings
10 Wings Served With Ranch or Blue Cheese And Celery
Boneless Wings
10 Wings Served With Ranch or Blue Cheese And Celery
Wings
Soups & Salads
Side Salad
House or Caesar
Chicken Salad
Hand Breaded or Grilled, Cheddar, Bacon, Tomato, Croutons
Chef Salad
Ham, Turkey, Egg, Bacon, Cheddar, Tomato, Croutons
Wedge Salad
Iceberg Wedge, Bacon, Bleu Cheese Crumbles, Red Onion, Tomato, Bleu Cheese Dressing
Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled Chicken, Parmesan, Croutons
Ham & Bean Soup
Chili
Deluxe
Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Mushroom, Black Olives, Green Pepper, Onion
BBQ Chicken
Grilled Chicken, Red Onion, BBQ Sauce
Meat Lovers
Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Italian Sausage, Bacon
Cheese Pizza
Build Your Own
Hawaiian
Ham, Pineapple, BBQ Sauce
Pizza
Burgers
Texas BBQ Burger
Cheddar, Bacon, BBQ Sauce, Onion Ring
Bacon Bleu Burger
Bacon, Bleu Cheese Crumbles
Patty Melt
Marble Rye, Sautéed Onions, Swiss, 1000 Island
Shroom Burger
Sautéed Mushrooms, Swiss
Build Your Own Burger
Cheeses: American | Swiss | Cheddar | Pepper Jack. Toppings: Banana Pepper | Jalapeno | Grilled Onions | Grilled Mushrooms | Pico. Premium Toppings: Bacon | Bleu Cheese Crumbles | Onion Ring | Guacamole
Spicy Chicken
Hand Breaded or Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Pico, Chipotle Sauce, Bonfire Rub
Bourbon Cola Brisket
House Smoked Brisket, Shredded Pepper Jack Pickled Red Onion, Bourbon Cola Sauce
BBQ Pulled Pork
House Smoked Pork, BBQ Rub, Cheese, Pico, BBQ Sauce
Boom Boom Shrimp
Breaded Popcorn Shrimp, Lettuce, Pico, Boom Boom Sauce
Beef Tacodilla
Shredded Beef, Cheese, Pico, Guacamole, Sour Cream, Grilled Tortilla
Tacos
Sandwiches
Tenderloin
Pork Loin, Hand Breaded or Grilled
Texas Toast BLT
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Texas Toast
Fish Sandwich
Hand-Breaded Haddock
Chicken Sandwich
Hand Breaded or Grilled
Beef Brisket Sandwich
House-Smoked Brisket. Side of BBQ Sauce
Pulled Pork Sandwich
House-Smoked Pork, Side of BBQ Sauce
Chicken Wrap
Hand Breaded or Grilled, Pico, Lettuce, Cheese, Chipotle Sauce
Grilled Ham & Cheese
Smoked Pit Ham. Choice of Cheese And Bread
Cuban Sandwich
Ham, Pulled Pork, Mustard, Pickle, Hoagie Bun
Fries
Potato Salad
Cottage Cheese
Green Beans
Cole Slaw
Apple Sauce
Sides
Desserts
Bread Pudding
Cinnamon Sauce
Brownie ala Mode
Brownie, Vanilla Ice Cream, Whipped Cream, Chocolate Syrup
Chicken Fingers
With fries
7-inch Cheese Pizza
Mini Corn Dogs
With fries
Grilled Cheese
With fries