Welcome to New Bethel Ordinary
At New Bethel Ordinary, we celebrate the heart of American dining through our diverse pizza offerings and hearty appetizers. Nestled in Indianapolis, this casual eatery is perfect for families and groups alike, with extensive vegetarian options and a welcoming atmosphere. Our story is rooted in bringing the community together over delicious food—whether you're enjoying hand-breaded chicken strips, zesty nachos, or our signature pizzas. With convenient delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating, we aim to make every meal a joyous occasion. At New Bethel Ordinary, every dish is crafted with care, ensuring a memorable dining experience for everyone.
-
8838 Southeastern Ave Indianapolis, IN 46239 United States Hotline: (317) 862-5020
Introducing New Bethel Ordinary: A Gem in Indianapolis
If you find yourself in the bustling heart of Indianapolis, make sure to swing by New Bethel Ordinary, a delightful eatery that redefines the pizza experience. Nestled at 8838 Southeastern Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46239, this American pizzeria combines familiarity with a touch of creativity, offering a menu designed to cater to both your appetite and your mood.
Why Choose New Bethel Ordinary?
New Bethel Ordinary is not just a pizza place; it’s a hub for food enthusiasts looking for quality and comfort. With options for delivery, takeout, and even reservations, this establishment makes it easy for everyone to enjoy a laid-back meal. The atmosphere is casual yet inviting, ideal for both family dinners and friendly gatherings.
Diverse Menu Highlights
The menu features an impressive array of options to satisfy any craving:
- Appetizers include crowd favorites like Fried Ravioli and Beer Battered Onion Rings, all perfect for sharing.
- Wings lovers will find traditional or boneless options that come with your choice of dipping sauce.
- A variety of salads and soups provide fresh options, such as the hearty Chicken Caesar Salad and seasonal Chili.
Of course, the real stars of New Bethel Ordinary are the pizzas. Whether you opt for a classic cheese or a more adventurous topping combination, each pizza is crafted to perfection, using high-quality ingredients that guarantee a delightful bite every time. The crust is the right balance of crisp and chewy, making it impossible to stop at just one slice!
Family-Friendly & Accommodating
New Bethel Ordinary is perfect for families, offering many vegetarian options and dishes that kids will love. With features like outdoor seating, dog-friendly policies, and a full bar, it's a place where everyone can feel welcome. Plus, the presence of television screens makes it a great spot for catching the latest sports game while enjoying hearty food.
Join the Buzz
For those who appreciate a bustling scene with moderate noise, New Bethel Ordinary serves as an excellent venue for both lunch and dinner. With ample street parking and amenities like Wi-Fi and bike parking, convenience is just a visit away. And don’t forget to ask about catering options for your next event!
In conclusion, if you are in search of a place that expertly melds comfort with fantastic American cuisine, look no further than New Bethel Ordinary. Indulge in delicious pizzas and more, and let your taste buds revel in every bite.
Contact them today at (317) 862-5020 and embark on a culinary adventure that’s just a slice away!
We love the food at Ordinary! Haven't had anything we didn't like. Service is usually top notch, even when busy. One of our favorites is the meat lovers pizza-one slice fills you up! Loaded with meat. Sitting outside during nice warmer months is a plus, with a few games for the kids. Great place for a little town.
Fattest pizza in town and I don't mean the crust. This or traditional crust loaded with big thick toppings and a ton of cheese. These pizzas are super heavy. If you don't like pizza that's OK because they have a large menu with lots of items. Bar area with a wide variety of craft beers. My wife loves the bread pudding.
Really good pizza and beer they have a baurbon beer called Dragons milk, very good beer
I've only had their pizza... but with that said....awesome, awesome pizza!!! Food and service consistently good.
Just wanted leave a quick positive review for a great place. I ordered wings and 10 inch pizza. It was ready when I got there, staff was quick and polite. Food was great, I was recommended to this place from someone I trust, so I didn't expect anything less. I was not disappointed. I'm from out of town, but I'm eating here again before I leave! Thanks again for the great food and service.
FOLLOWUP ON MY REVIEW It's been a few days since my initial review, and I just wanted to add a few afterthoughts to my experience with the large Meatlovers from New Bethel Ordinary. I have had 1 piece each day since. There are 8 triangle slices on the pizza and each one has been enough to satisfy a decent appetite. I heated the slices with an infrared toaster oven, which heats from the inside out. The pizza was $29, including tax. That comes to about $3.63 per slice. If you think about it, that's not particularly cheap. But I must say, each re-heated pie slice has been very good. I have added a couple of pics to show what the leftover slices look like. I wouldn't get this pizza too often, but it really hits the spot once in a while.
I ordered a pizza for carry out. Service was very excellent, and so was the pizza. Cooked to perfection! Would definitely return again. When they handed me the pizza, I was shocked at how heavy it was. This is a loaded pizza!
We went on a Thursday Night, and it was a packed house. Very quickly some put us on the short waitlist. Our server was very friendly and attentive. All of the food was very good. The meat lovers pizza had pepperoni, sausage and bacon. One piece and I was full. The boneless wings had a great tasting breading. The house made sauce was amazing.
I grew up eating here regularly, and let me tell you Ordinary does not miss. Every single time I've eaten here (mostly takeout) has been delicious. This time we dined in on a busy evening. We were promptly seated. The waitress greeted us timely. We had the breadsticks and loaded fries for an appetizer. Both were great. I love the cheese that comes with the breadsticks. We built our own pizza. You HAVE to get the crumble sausage on any pizza you get here. It's the best!! I cannot recommend Ordinary enough!
Seems like I've always have a solid experience when I come...and tonight was no different (first time dropping a review after being on Yelp though) This place always drops some fire (insert fire emoji) My wife and I went on a busy Saturday night. We were quoted 45 minutes for a table...and got a text 2 minutes after checking in that we could be seated. The waitress came and got our drink and food orders quick- there was a mishap with my wife's drink but the waitress quickly corrected it. We hadn't ate all day, so our stomachs were bigger than our appetite. We split a half order of breadsticks, cheese fries, a 12in pizza, and I had a side salad. Breadsticks: crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside. Cheese was a little spicy but delicious. Cheese Fries: can't go wrong here. Plenty of seasoning on the fries, lots of cheese and bacon- could have done with some more ranch but that's my problem for not asking for more Pizza: if you are a fan of crumbly sausage, this is the place to go. Some of the best pizza around. Nuf said. Side salad: I couldn't believe my eyes when it came out- it was huge for the price. I ordered Italian with it, but honestly unsure if that was what came out. Whatever it was, it was delicious. A+ service as well: after we left, we forgot our leftovers, and the waitress ran out the restaurant and gave them to us. Never can go wrong with this place.